I like the color I chose but it doesn't stay on very well, has a tendency to smear throughout the day and wear off. Does not keep a clean line.
Submitted on May 14, 2015
Awful. Dark brown is actually rusty red. "Natural" ingredients left me with red puffy eyes for 2 days.
Submitted on May 7, 2015
I was excited about the natural ingredients, but agreed with other reviewers that it is very difficult to apply. I tried to flatten out the point because this is for the eyelid, not an eyebrow, but what finally worked was to lay down several lines of pigment on the tip of my finger, use a little moisturizer to blend, and then apply to my eyelid. But that was enough trouble that I haven't used it more than twice.
Submitted on Apr 10, 2015
I'm giving it one star just for the attempt to make this a safe product. The color was not good for me and I had racoon eyes before I left the house. I'm sending it back. On with the search for the perfect eyeliner.
Submitted on Mar 11, 2015
Does not glide on smoothly.
Submitted on Feb 12, 2015
One of my biggest pet peeves with pencils is they are too dry going on, and sharpening them creates a short stumpy tip rendering them useless & a waste a money. Not with this pencil - it applies creamy & evenly, and sharpens nicely just like the tip it came with.
Submitted on Feb 9, 2015
Not that great, I find it hard to get on my eyes and it doesn't stay on. Disappointed.
Submitted on Feb 7, 2015
I don't wear much, if any make-up, but a little eyeliner under my bottom lashes helps bring out my eyes. I have even contemplated liner-tattoos, since I so seldom use a liner and when I do, I tend to forget and rub it off. This pencil is awesome! It stays on even when I do rub my eyes and it has convinced me I don't need to indulge in the expense and pain of permanent liner.
Submitted on Dec 10, 2013
I do like this product. Goes on nice and smooth.
Submitted on Sep 15, 2013
I wrote a more detailed review of the black pencil, so I will be brief here. I wish the color was darker. There is a lot of red in this pencil's color. It is difficult to apply. I am not sure if I would order this product again or not.
Submitted on May 14, 2013
Glad there is a product that is safe to use.
Submitted on May 7, 2013
I love this product. It is so easy to use and the results are remarkable and safe.
Submitted on Mar 15, 2013
Excellent product. Easy to use.
Submitted on Nov 25, 2012
Everyone has commented on it. I am so sensitive to additives that I have not been able to wear liner in years. Excellent so far. I have not had to sharpen it yet though, so we will see.
Submitted on Nov 5, 2012
I haven't worn eyeliner pencil in years because I was concerned about the chemical issues. This applies very smoothly and easily and I don't have to worry about what's getting into my system. It stays on nicely, yet my cleansing wipes remove it with one or two swipes when I'm getting ready for bed. I'm not a big makeup wearer, but eyeliner helps my eyes stand out a bit more behind my eyeglasses, and I'm very happy to have the choice to wear it again without exposure to harmful substances.
Submitted on Sep 24, 2012
The color is great; the pencil is well made.
Submitted on Sep 1, 2012
I had to send this product back - only because I realized that I severely need blephroplasty. My eyeline is completely covered up at this time. I did try the product on the edge of my eye and it seems like it would be a wonderful product. I'd say it's worth a try - unless you need eyelid surgery - then do that first!
Submitted on Aug 27, 2012
I'm giving this two stars based on the fact that is made of quality ingredients, like all Isabella products. I really, really wanted to love this product, but I just didn't. I couldn't get a thin enough line, and the color looked red on me rather than brown.
Submitted on Jul 25, 2012
Goes on smoothly in a nice fine line.
Submitted on Jul 23, 2011
I liked the pencil, the color, and the ease of application, for me....it stung my eyes. I do have a problem with sensitivity so it was not good for me. Otherwise I would have loved it.
Submitted on Jul 16, 2011
This product is everything the catalog says! The texture is just right - it applies easily without tugging - but it also stays put throughout the day without smudging. I'm delighted.
Submitted on Jul 8, 2011
I really liked this eye liner. Would like it to come in a dark brown, the brown makes my eyes look kinda red.
Submitted on Jun 28, 2011
Nice coverage -- did smear after awhile.
Submitted on Jun 24, 2011
I love this product. It is pure and long lasting. I highly recommend it.
Submitted on Mar 25, 2010
I love this eye pencil. I used a liquid eyeliner before and this is so great. It doesn't bother my sensitive eyes either.
Submitted on Feb 4, 2010
This pencil was too soft and smudgy. At this price, I wish it hadn't left me looking like a raccoon.
Submitted on Nov 30, 2009