Did not stay on at all. Extremely disappointing
Submitted on May 11, 2015
I like that this pencil is not jet black giving me that witch craft look. I do notice it doesn't have the durability as another liner I have used in the past but knowing I'm not putting chemicals so close to my eyes makes up for it.
Submitted on Apr 9, 2015
very pleasant to apply, but does not stay!
Submitted on Apr 6, 2015
Great ingredients, texture, and lasting power.
Submitted on Feb 7, 2015
I haven't worn eyeliner in a while because they all smudge on me. I was hoping this one would be different but it wasn't.
Submitted on Jan 16, 2015
This is the nicest eye pencil I have used in a long time. It's easy to use, easy to sharpen and the color stays where you put it. Thanks.
Submitted on Dec 6, 2014
I am so happy to finally find an eye pencil that doesnt hurt my eyes.It goes on really easy and lasts all day.
Submitted on Dec 1, 2014
Always prefer something safe, especially around the eyes. This works well and doesn't present a hassle when it needs to be sharpened.
Submitted on Aug 16, 2013
I really appreciate a product that does not contain parabens. This pencil is not quite as creamy as what I was using but I am still very happy with it and my eyes are happier too!
Submitted on Jun 13, 2013
I like this eye pencil a lot. It looks more glamorous than any one I've ever used. It does migrate like every pencil liner I've ever used. I just line the upper and then it looks like I also lined the lower. It fades but not more than usual. It's nice and soft to use and can easily be smudged.
Submitted on Jun 13, 2013
I like the idea of this pencil being made from more friendly to people ingredients. I do wish it would go on easier. I have trouble getting the pencil to apply properly. It goes on very reluctantly and I have to go over and over the areas I want covered. It doesn't stay on any longer than any other kind of eye pencils I have used before. If you are planning on being somewhere for an entire day, it might be a good idea to take the pencil along so that you can refresh your eye makeup as you need. . .
Submitted on May 14, 2013
I finally found an eye liner that is perfect! It goes on smoothly and doesn't flake, the color is just right and it stays put all day long. The point stays sharp for a long time and I've had it now for over a month and it still doesn't need sharpening. At the end of the day it comes off easily with either water and soap or eye make-up remover. I'd say this item is a winner!
Submitted on May 1, 2013
Sent it back...couldn't get any color off the pencil onto my eye area....disappointing!!
Submitted on Feb 9, 2013
Submitted on Jan 15, 2013
This eyeliner is amazing. I have tried others since I first tried it and nothing stays on longer goes on easier or lasts longer. This pencil lasts 6 months or more . . . Buying an all natural eyeliner is challenging, most do not stay on well; the liner ends up under my eye and I need to reapply several times a day. This one does not. I highly recommend it.
Submitted on Jan 13, 2013
I cant use this product. I was really hopeful, but it burns my eyes.
Submitted on Sep 20, 2012
Great item if you have a steady hand. Very happy that it's fairly safe to use around eyes.
Submitted on Aug 28, 2012
Ouch! Pencil 'lead' is HARD as a ROCK. Not desirable for tender eye area. Though, once coaxed on, it stays put and doesn't burn eyes.
Submitted on Aug 15, 2012
I am having some trouble getting used to using this. I think it will be easier when the very sharp point wears down a bit. I like the consistency and it smudges easily.
Submitted on Jul 21, 2012
This liner is too red, goes on with difficulty, and worst of all, is too big for standard sharpeners! Not worth the money at all!
Submitted on Nov 29, 2011
Did not like; it came off too easy.
Submitted on Jun 26, 2011
I really like this eyeliner. It goes on easily and stays on for the whole day I admit that I powder it lightly with eyeshadow in hot weather although I don't know if it is necessary - it's more just habit. It can be purposely smudged and that stays too. The only thing that could be better is the tiny bits of flaking upon application. They are easily flicked away so - not really a problem after all.
Submitted on Jun 24, 2011